Storage
Cards for your PDA: Memory
Card Product Reviews by Lisa
Gade, Editor-in-Chief, March 27, 2002 (updated 2/2004)
(Read
Storage Options for your PDA: an explanation of the different types
of cards here.)
SanDisk
SD (Secure Digital) Cards www.sandisk.com,
prices vary with capacity, 5 year warranty
SanDisk is one of the big names in
the storage card arena. Heck, they invented the CompactFlash
card in 1994, and worked jointly with Matsushita (known
mostly by the name Panasonic in this country) and Toshiba
to develop the SD memory card. We've been using their CF
cards for years and the SD cards have worked perfectly
for us in a Palm m130, i705, Casio E-200 and iPAQ 3835.
We've tested their 32 meg and 128 meg cards. Transfer speeds
are excellent, and we haven't experienced MediaPlayer skips
and stutters on the iPAQ 3800 series (that iPAQ has some
speed issues with SD cards because of the way Compaq implemented
SD). SanDisk is the OEM manufacturer of Compaq SD cards.
Buying hint: Compaq marks up the price of their cards,
buy SanDisk instead! The cards come with a protective case.
SimpleTech
SD (Secure Digital) Cards www.simpletech.com,
prices vary with capacity, 1 year warranty
SimpleTech is another big name in
the storage card arena. They've been around for over a
decade and make all kinds of memory products. Their cards
are widely available and competitively priced. We've been
using their CF cards for years in a variety of PDAs and
digital cameras, and the 64 and 128 meg SD cards we tested
have worked perfectly for us in a Palm m130, m515, iPAQ
3835 and Toshiba e740. Transfer speeds are excellent (max
transfer speed is 2MB/sec), and the cards are fully compatible
with the SD Memory Card Physical Layer Specification version
1.01, File System Specification version 1.01, and Security
Specification version 1.01. The cards come with a protective
case.
MemPlug CF Springboard Module
for Handspring Visor handhelds Portable Innovation Technology www.memplug.com,
price $49.95 for CF and SmartMedia version, $69.95 for SD/MMC and
MemoryStick versions
Now, this is one cool invention! Springboard
memory and backup modules have been very expensive (around
$59 for an 16 meg module). CompactFlash (CF) cards are the
cheapest storage card technology these days, and they're readily
available and fast. Wish you could use CF cards with your Visor?
MemPlug CF lets you do just that. It's a Springboard module
that has a built-in CF type I slot.
They also have models that accept, SD/MMC
cards, MemorySticks and SmartMedia cards. If you've got a
collection of these cards from your digital camera, MP3 player
or old PDA you're in luck.
You'll get a group of utilities with your MemPlug,
including PiBackup a program that allows you to backup your handheld
to a storage card, PiMover, which moves files and databases between
your Visor and a memory card, gMovie movie viewer and more. Quite
a generous bundle for the price.
Our test CF unit worked flawlessly, even on a Visor
Deluxe with the now ancient 3.1 OS. The bundled programs were just
what we needed to take advantage of the storage card technology and
worked without a hitch. If you need more memory for your Visor, get
this module!
CompactFlash Memory Cards:
SanDisk and Viking SanDisk | Viking,
prices vary depending on capacity, 5 year warranty
SanDisk invented the
CompactFlash and as you can imagine, they're one of the names you
can trust when shopping for a CF card. Over the past 6 years we've
used just about every capacity CF card made by these folks with never
a problem or a worry. Transfer speeds are excellent and beat most
no-name cards in our tests. SanDisk has come out with a "faster" CF
card, which promises to improve picture-taking times for digital
cameras. We'll be testing one in our PDAs soon and will update with
the results.
Viking is
another old name, though they aren't a standards creator and product
innovator like SanDisk. Viking started out as a PC memory manufacturer
and branched out to CompactFlash memory several years ago. We've
also been using Viking CF cards in PDAs and digital cameras and have
found them to be reliable, fast and reasonably priced. The cards
come with a protective case.
SimpleTech CompactFlash
Memory Cards www.simpletech.com,
prices vary with capacity, 1 year warranty
SimpleTech
is another big name in the storage card arena. They've been
around for over a decade and make all kinds of memory products.
Their cards are widely available and competitively priced.
We've been using their CF cards for years in a variety of
PDAs and digital cameras, and the 256 and 512 meg CF cards
we tested have worked perfectly for us in an iPAQ
3835, NEC MobilePro P300, Toshiba
e740 and HP digital cameras. We used these cards to play
some long movies (MPEGs and AVIs) and ran intensive games
off of them such as X-Ranger and Hyperspace
Delivery Boy.
Transfer speeds are excellent achieving
sustained write speeds up to 1.5 Megabytes/second and burst
speeds up to 8 Megs/second. They are forward compatibility
to Secure CF cards.
The cards come with a protective case.
CompactFlash
memory cards: Silicon Storage Technology (SST) SST, prices
vary depending on capacity, 1 year warranty
Though not a household name
among retail customers, Silicon Storage Technology has been
making memory products since 1989. Located in Northern California,
SST has been making all kinds of flash memory products for
years, including PC BIOS chips, ATA Disk chips and more.
Their cards are quite fast,
with 1.4 MByte/sec write times and read times of 6 Mbyte/sec.
burst. Reliability has been excellent for our 128 meg card.
Transferring a card between an HP digital camera and an iPAQ
worked perfectly with no card corruption.
The cards come with a protective
case.
CompactFlash
memory cards: Butterfly Media Butterfly
Media, prices vary depending on capacity, lifetime warranty
Another smaller company, Butterfly
Media is located in Los Angeles, and has been in the memory
making business since 1998. They also make PC memory, notebook
memory, SD and SmartMedia cards. They began making CompactFlash
cards in 1999, and offer a range of sizes (currently 8 - 256
meg) all made in L.A.
Reliability and speed have
been good on the 32 meg and 128 megs cards we tested. Butterfly
cards have transfer rates that are quite good: Read 3.2Mbyte/sec
Max. Write 0.6Mbyte/sec Max. Transferring a card between
an HP digital camera and an iPAQ worked perfectly with no
card corruption.
The cards come with a protective
case.
Butterfly sells direct via
their web
site, and also through Fry's Electronics stores.
Delkin has been making
memory products in the San Diego, California area since 1986.
That's a long time in the high tech world! They call their
cards "eFilm" and
eFilm memory cards come in CompactFlash, SmartMedia, MultiMedia,
SD Card, and PC Card formats. That said, they aren't just for digital
cameras!
This is the only CompactFlash
card we've seen that actually comes with a mini-CD ROM
of bundled software. You'll get software such as "Digital Camera Suite", "Explorer" to
view and catalog digital images, MP3 software and more. Not
bad! Delkin cards are at times priced higher than some competitors,
but the software bundle could make it worthwhile for you.
The cards come with a protective case.
SanDisk MMC (MultiMedia Cards)
SanDisk MMC cards (MultiMedia
Card) were jointly developed by SanDisk, Matsushita and Toshiba.
SanDisk MMC cards are available in 16, 32 and 64 meg capacities.
We've used their MMC cards in various Palm PDAs with SD slots
and the Casio E-200 and iPAQ 3800 series. In all cases there
were no compatibility issues and despite the fact that MMC
cards are slower than SD cards, we didn't experience painful
waits while programs launched and data was accessed except
in the case of Pocket Windows Media player on the Pocket PCs.
We did notice occasional stutters with MMC cards compared to
SD cards. Not SanDisk's fault, but rather than fact that SD
cards have faster transfer rates than MMC cards.
The cards come with a protective case.
Toshiba PC Card Hard Drives: 2 and 5 gig PCMCIA
card drives Toshiba,
$299 for 2 gig, $399 for 5 gig, 1 year warranty
Toshiba is the
inventor of one of the small miracles in portable computing:
the 1.8 PC Card hard drive. They've been one of the big innovators
and manufacturers of notebook computer hard drives for several
years, so they're a name you can trust in micro storage. These
PCMCIA cards actually have little spinning platters inside,
same as your notebook hard drive, only smaller. These are available
in 2 gig and 5 gig capacities, and the technology has been
around for a few years now, and has proven to be reliable.
You can also insert one of these cards
into a PC or Mac notebook's PC Card slot in order to transfer
files, or to use it as a secondary hard drive. Any PDA that
can accept PCMCIA cards, such as the Compaq iPAQ with
a PC Card expansion sleeve can use these cards for storage
in the same fashion you'd use a CompactFlash card.
Toshiba 2 gig PC Card Hard Drive and Case
Does it seem a little weird hearing a disk drive
ever so quietly humming inside your PDA? Well, yes, but you'll get
used to it. Do
you need to worry that these drives have internal moving parts and
may thus be more delicate and consume more battery power than a solid
state storage card such as a CF, MMC or SD card? Yes. PC Card hard
drives and the IBM microdrive do consume more power since the internal
disk platters must be spinning when the drive is in use. However,
if the drive is not currently being used, then the platters will
stop spinning until you need to access programs or files on the disk.
This will save power. Some PDA PC Card expansion sleeves have internal
batteries to help offset the more power-hungry nature of PC Cards.
And you do have to be more careful with any high tech device that
has moving parts. Solid State cards aren't susceptible to damage
due to movement, shaking and bouncing while hard drives are. Take
care when handling your PDA (as I hope you do!) and keep the card
in the nice rubber-isolated storage case that comes with your hard
drive and you should be just fine.
Speed of these PC Card hard drives is very good
thanks to a 15ms access time and 4,200 RPM rotational speed (similar
to notebook hard drive specs) and the 16 bit data bus they use to
interface with your PDA. And they won't weigh you down much at just
under 2 ounces (55 grams).
SanDisk Memory Stick Cards www.sandisk.com,
prices vary with capacity, 5 year warranty
Standard Memory Sticks
SanDisk is one of the big names in
the storage card arena. Heck, they invented the CompactFlash
card in 1994, and worked jointly with Matsushita (known
mostly by the name Panasonic in this country) and Toshiba
to develop the SD memory card. Most recently they worked
with Sony to develop the new high capacity, high speed
Memory Stick PRO cards that will be coming out in 2003.
So they're a name you can trust when it comes to Memory
Sticks, and you can often find them at major retailers
for a few bucks less than Sony brand sticks.
We've used their Memory Sticks, up to the
128 meg capacity, in Sony PDAs such as the SJ30, NR70V and
NX70V without a problem. They behave nicely in card readers
and generally make us happy campers. Transfer rates are excellent,
and those of you who use Memory Stick devices should be pleased
to know that they are one of the fastest memory technologies
used in PDAs and digicams.
Memory Stick Pro
These cards were released in the Spring
of 2003, first by Sony and then by Sandisk. The Pro cards
were a joint development effort between Sony and Sandisk,
so you can trust you're getting the same quality that you'll
find in the Sony branded Pro cards. They come in 3 capacities:
256 meg, 512 meg and 1 gig. Not only do they offer larger
capacity than regular Memory Sticks, but they're faster.
Just how fast depends on the device you're using the card
with. Devices with native Memory Stick Pro support show greater
than 33% faster overall speeds improvements compared to regular
sticks. Read and db access are the most improved. I tested
the 256 meg Memory Stick Pro against a 128 meg Sandisk Memory
Stick using VFSMark on an NX80V, which has native support
for Pro. Each card had 60 megs of identical data on them.
The VFSMark overall score for the Pro card was 251, compared
to 160 for the standard stick (higher numbers are better).
Not bad! A great choice if you like to watch videos on your
Clie, and want the quickest image writes when taking photos
with the built-in camera.
Sony NX, NZ and TG models are compatible
with the Memory Stick Pro format. The NX73V, NX80V and TG50
have native support. For older NX models and the NZ90, you'll
need to install a Sony-supplied driver. Some recent Sony
cameras also support the Pro format.